Alice on the Outside
Author: Phyllis Naylor
Publishing Info: Atheneum Books for Young Readers 1999


DISCLAIMER: Because of the potentially foul language, sexually explicit scenarios or other graphic situations, you must be 18 years or older to view this material. By doing so, you also agree that OFSA is NOT liable for damages to you of any kind.

Summary from the Library of Congress cataloging-in-Publication Data: Eighth-grader Alice has lots of questions about sex, relationships, prejudice and change.

Excerpts/Notes:

The LOC Publication Data speaks for itself, but the book also touches on lesbianism.

Cousin C. is staying over at their house and sharing a room with Alice: “she’d [C.] come back to the bedroom, slip off her robe, and put on her panties and bra…had my eyes half-closed, but when a twenty-five-year-old woman is standing stark naked…I think you’re allowed a peek…can learn a lot just by looking…[she] lets her breasts fall into the bra cups…you get your nipples where they’re supposed to be, I thought…couldn’t wait to tell E. and P. [her friends]…[she] didn’t know I was watching…squirts of cologne between her breasts, and talcum powder beneath…may she had learned how to drop her breasts into a bra and powder…[at night] she’d crawl under the blanket and we’d tell each other stuff…I’d been wanting to know…What is sexual intercourse really, really like for a woman? …how do you just come right out and ask…(20-21).”

They talk about C’s divorce, then the next 3 pages are full of a conversation about SEX!

On pages 28-31, she discusses sex with her friends.

Alice thinks about her boyfriend: “He didn’t touch my breasts – he almost did – but I’ll have to admit I sort of wanted him to…that’s what sex is about…you’re supposed to want to caress each other. It’s supposed to feel good. It’s natural. It’s normal (67).”

They shop for dresses for a dance. Among them, short and revealing dresses (85).

She goes over for a night at L.H.’s house: [L.H.] rubbed one of her feet gently against mine…L. reads her palm: “When she finished, she didn’t let go of my hand…she still had a hold of it. “I really like you, Alice.” “I really like you too.” “That’s not what I meant,” said Lori. …I figured out what this was all about… “You passed the first test. You didn’t run screaming…” “Why should I?” “You know what I mean, don’t you?” “That you like girls…romantically, I mean?” “Yeah, I think so” “Oh, gosh, I came on too strong…I shouldn’t have hurried you.” “…I could never fall in love with you. Not like that.” “You were always so nice to me. I guess I hoped.” Alice asks if she should leave. L. H. admits that her mom does not know she is a lesbian…”Hardly anyone does.” “What made you think I did?” “…You smiled at me, that’s all…I’ve heard of girls who went with boys first before they realized they were gay…Well, lesbian. There. I’ve said it…I’ve never had a girlfriend before, but I’d like to.” I tried to imagine what my own mother would say if I told her I was a lesbian…I didn’t ever know my own mother…L.H. speaking again: “For the past few years, it’s the feeling that I’m really interested in girls…I love them, the way a guy would love them.” Alice is thinking: I wondered why people seem so afraid that someone who’s gay or lesbian might make a pass at them (97-103).

She is talking to her dad and brother: “No, I was just wondering what you would say if I told you I was a lesbian.” Her dad: “Is this a hypothetical question?” “…yes…” “I suppose I’d be disappointed…a little bit sad…happy for you…if you found someone you could love.” “I just spent the night with a lesbian…L.H. said she liked me and she gave me a bracelet…I told her I don’t feel the same…we’re just friends.” “I’m glad you’re still friends.” Her brother is speaking: …a gay approached a friend of mine in the men’s room, and my friend decked him…[and] going around bragging about it…a guy who has to answer a proposal with a left to the chin is protesting a little too much (110-112).”

Clearly, this is a book that not only discusses sex, but lesbianism. Could it be that the discussion of homosexuality is to promote tolerance and acceptance? Her father congratulates her for remaining friends with a lesbian. He tells Alice when she puts forth a hypothetical that he “would be happy” for her if she found “someone to love.” She never left L.H.’s house after finding out who she was, and in this book, L.H. plainly comes on to her. There is no subtle hint to look for, but this book describes what Alice is thinking and how she does not see why anyone is “afraid” of gays. If you’ve not read through some of the other books listed, I recommend you do so. Your money is hard at work here – schools have the opportunity to buy books like this for their libraries – and again, all with YOUR money.

An April 25, 2005 PABBIS news release says it all:

Tolerance, acceptance and diversity teachings in schools have nothing to do with civility and human decency – nothing. Like so many of the other books OFSA listed on its website, this is about questioning values and altering those values to fit the view of what so many other groups want for YOUR kids. – M. Lyn